CRIMINAL LAW – FINAL EXAM 2013
PART 1: SECTION 9 (ARBITRARY DETENTION AND ARREST) 1
R v Grant 2009 SCC 1
R v Suberu 2009 SCC 2
PART 2: SECTION 10(B) (RIGHT TO COUNSEL) 2
Informational/Implementational duty 2
Christie v York 2008 SCC 3
R v GJ 2009 3
R v Sinclair 2010 SCC 4
Bond “Cost of the Crisis” 4
PART 3: SECTION 8, SEARCH AND SEIZURE 5
R v Tessling 2004 SCC 5
R v Patrick 2009 SCC 5
Hunter v Southam 1984 SCC + steps 6
R v Golden 2001 SCC 7
R v Bonds 2010 ONCJ 7
PART 4: EXCLUSION OF EVIDENCE 8
Charter analysis sequence for exclusion notes 8
Grant/Harrison test for exclusion 9
R v Harrison 2009 SCC 9
R v Grant 2009 SCC 10
R v Kang Brown 2008 SCC 10
R v AM 2008 SCC 10
WINTER SEMESTER – PART 1: EVIDENCE AND PROOF 11
Woolmington v DPP 1935 12
R v Oakes 1986 SCC 12
R v Whyte 1988 SCC 13
R v Keegstra 1990 SCC 13
R v Downey 1992 SCC (presumption of innocence) 14
R v Lifchus 1997 SCC 14
R v Star 2000 SCC 14
Figure 1: Doubt Mountain (s. 9 and s 8 offences and defences) 15
PART 2: ACTUS REUS REQUIREMENTS 16
Kilbride v Lake 1962 17
R v Brown 1997 ONCA 17
R v Thornton 1991 ONCA 18
R v Currier 1998 SCC 18
R v Mabior 2012 SCC 19
R v DC 2012 SCC 19
Homicide Matrix 20
Pagett v The Queen 1983 21
Intervening Acts Where Causation Can be Severed 21
Smithers v The Queen 1978 SCC 21
R v Cribbin 1999 ONCA 22
R v Reid & Stratton 2003 NSCA 22
R v Harbottle 1993 SCC 22
R v Nette 2001 SCC 23
PART 3: MENS REA 23
Standards of Fault 24
R v Steane 1947 25
R v Hibbert 1995 SCC 25
R v Buzzanga and Durocher ONCA 1979 25
R v Beaver 1957 SCC 26
R v Sansregret 1985 SCC 26
R v Briscoe 2010 SCC 27
R v Vaillancourt 1987 27
R v Martineau 1990 SCC 28
R v Arkell 1990 SCC 28
R v Tutton and Tutton 1989 SCC 28
R v Hundal 1993 SCC 29
R v Creighten 1993 SCC 29
R v Beatty 2008 SCC 30
Absolute and Strict Liability 31
R v Sault Ste Marie 1978 SCC 31
Reference Re: BC Motor Vehicle Act 1985 SCC 31
R v Wholesale Travel Group 1991 SCC 32
PART 4: MISTAKE OF FACT AND LAW 32
Consent and Assault 32
R v Jobidon 1991 SCC 33
R v Ewanchuck 1999 SCC 33
R v JA 2012 SCC 34
R v Cuerrier 1998 SCC 34
Mistake of Fact 34
Pappajohn v R 1980 SCC 35
Requirements to prove assault 36
R v Sansregret 1985 SCC 36
R v Seaboyer 1991 36
Mistake of Law 37
R v Campbell 1973 38
Incapacity 38
Youth 38
Mental Disorder – NCRMD 39
R v Chaulk 1990 SCC 39
R v Swain 1991 SCC 39
Intoxication 40
R v Daviault 1993 SCC 40
PART 5: DEFENCES 41
R v Whynot (Stafford) 1983 NSCA 41
R v Lavallee 1990 SCC 42
R v Malott 1996 42
R v Ruzic 2001 SCC 43
R v Latimer 2001 SCC 44
R v Hibbert 1995 SCC 44
R v Ryan 2013 SCC 44
Necessity 46
R v Latimer 2001 SCC 46
R v Tran 2010 SCC 46
Automatism 47
R v Rabey 1997 48
R v Parks 1992 SCC...